Dhanuka Agritech Ltd – Betting on the Coming Agri Revolution

Dhanuka Agritech is an agri-chemicals (herbicides, pesticides and insecticides) formulation manufacturing and marketing company which has over 82 products, reaches over 1 Cr (10 mi) farmers, had revenues of more than Rs 650 Crs, EBIDTA of Rs 88 Crs and PAT of Rs 65 Crs in FY 2012-13, has bagged the Forbes Best under a billion award 3 times and has a 6% market share in the agro-chemicals sector.   

MAJOR INTERNATIONAL TIE-UPS AND AN ASSET LIGHT MODEL

As per CRISIL`s July 2013 report on the company, the company is in a tie up with 4 American, 4 Japanese, 1 Norwegian and 1 German multi-national agri-chemicals companies. The company with its strong distribution network is a perfect partner to these multi-nationals which have a strong technical expertise but are weak when it comes to marketing their products to the farmer. The company buys the technicals (chemicals that when mixed in the right proportion give the final formulation) from these companies, prepares the formulations and sells the same to the farmer directly.

As per in-Focus July 13 edition titled Indian Pesticide Industry: An Analysis,

“The costs associated with research, development and registration (pesticides must be approved by the Central Insecticides board) of new molecules (formulations) have increased substantially. On an average, it takes more than 9 years between first research and final authorization of the products. Indian companies have not focused on developing newer molecules due to absence of patent protection”.  

As per Emkay research dated October 2012, Dhanuka has achieved a FY 13 RoCE of 28.7% and a FY 14E RoCE of 29.9%. This matches up to its biggest competitor, Rallis India, which as per Emkay has a FY 13 RoCE of 29.6% and FY 14E RoCE of 30.5%.

Emkay goes onto add that  

“Dhanuka` s profit margins are 2nd highest in the industry (after Rallis) while asset light business model results into RoE (26%) higher than industry average by 300-400 bps”

Due to all the above tie-ups, the company has consistently been able to launch a slew of products each year which has helped in a healthy CAGR year on year.

MNREGA AND THE COMING AGRI BOOM

With MNREGA having an effect on farm labour  and Indian agriculture experiencing a mechanization and productivity boom, Dhanuka` s herbicide segment (19 products out of the company`s 82 products), has begun to take a bigger share of revenues (from 20% a few years back to 33% in FY-13 as per Emkay Oct 2010).

Below WSJ article talks about the coming boom in agricultural mechanization

http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052702304441404579121313326574626

Below 2 day old article on Mahindra`s 18% growth in tractor for Feb 2014 is another indication

http://www.google.co.in/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=8&ved=0CEwQqQIwBw&url=http%3A%2F%2Feconomictimes.indiatimes.com%2Fnews%2Fnews-by-industry%2Fauto%2Fautomobiles%2Fmahindra-tractor-sales-report-18-per-cent-growth-in-february%2Farticleshow%2F31217166.cms&ei=C40UU9XEAevxiAeon4CoCg&usg=AFQjCNHgr_xxpkWuDFV8u24PayEu-4EEcw&sig2=MT4Tujq_GRNg_CxKdbGgmw&bvm=bv.61965928,d.aGc

PROMOTER PROFILE

Promoters hold a healthy 74.99% stake in the company, take home 1.5% of the PAT margins as salaries and have been in the agro-chemicals business for a long time.

HEALTHY DIVIDEND PAYOUT AND CASH FLOWS

The company has paid out Rs 18.5 Crs of dividend in FY 13, Rs 11 Crs in FY 12 and Rs 10 Crs in FY 11. Although dividend yield (stock price/dividend payout) is less than 5%, the payout has been very consistent. Also, since FY 2011, the company has been seeing better cash flows from operating activities.

FII STAKE

41.25 lakh shares of Rs 2 face value at a premium of Rs 80 constituting 8.25% of the post issue paid up capital were issued on a preferential basis to Lighthouse funds. Since then, Lighthouse funds has been allowed to have one of its representatives on the board of the company. As per the company`s FY 13 annual report, the FII holding in the company stands at 8.25% indicating that there are no FII funds other than Lighthouse that have entered into the script.  

DEBT AND WORKING CAPITAL INTENSITY

Company has no long term debt. Short term debt of Rs 33 Crs is seen on its balance sheet. Company`s working capital as a percentage of sales has remained high at 38% for the past couple of years. This trend of high working capital (inventories and receivables are high) seems to be prevalent across all companies in this sector (as per CRISIL July 13 report on Dhanuka) and maybe due to the seasonal nature of demand (monsoon dependent business forces companies to hold a lot inventories).

LOTS OF IMPORTS, NO EXPORTS

Since, the company imports many technical grade chemicals, it has always had a big chunk of raw materials that have been imported. As per KREDENT Dec 2010 report on Dhanuka

“The company used to import over 70% of its key raw material in its initial year of operation”

For FY 13, the company imported only 30% of its raw materials. Nonetheless, the company is still vulnerable to foreign exchange fluctuations.

Also, since the company does not manufacture technical grade chemicals (unlike its peers Rallis India and United Phosphorous), the company does no exports.

BUY RECOMMENDATION RATIONALE

The script, over the past 2 years has been trading at a price band of 8-10 times earnings. For FY 14, the company has till date earned Rs 14/share. In March 13 quarter, the company had earned Rs 3.6/share. Assuming a similar earnings profile, the company will end up with Rs 17.5/share for FY 14, discounting the current market price of Rs 216 by a P/E (x) of 12.5 times.

Indian agriculture is slowly entering an era of high growth driven by rapid productivity increases and companies like Dhanuka (which will help farmers weed out herbs without employing additional farm hands) are going to be the biggest beneficiaries.

Rallis, which is a technicals manufacturer, a major exporter and which does substantially better on the working capital front is Dhanuka`s competitor and trades at a P/E(x) of 24 times.

Dhanuka Agritech is bound to touch new highs. The stock has been moving up substantially over the last 1.5 years and is bound to move up further.

 Disclaimer : I have bought stock at Rs 220/share

 

 

NIIT LTD – The McDonalds of the Education Business

Having impacted 35 million learners since inception, with a presence in over 40 countries and revenues of Rs 960 Crs, NIIT Ltd was rightly termed as the “McDonalds of Software Business” by the Far Eastern Economic review, 2000. The stock currently trades at Rs 25/share, taking its market cap to Rs 440 Crs. With total outstanding debt of Rs 112 Crs, the company is valued at an enterprise valuation of Rs 550 Crs.  

AREAS OF FOCUS

Individual learning, Corporate learning, School learning and Skill building solutions are the 4 major areas of focus for the company.

Individual Learning Solutions (ILS)

With nearly 1000 ILS centres around the world (approx 650 in India, 200 in China), the Individual Learning Solutions (ILS), which currently uses Cloud computing, is the company`s backbone, contributing to 50% of the overall revenues. ILS courses encompass a wide range of disciplines including IT, Engineering, Banking, Business Process Outsourcing (BPO), Insurance, Management etc. The company has tied up with a number of companies to impart training in the relevant sectors. SAP, Microsoft, Oracle, Intel etc for IT training; ICICI, Axis, HDFC and Yes Bank for Banking; GenPact, HCL, Wipro etc for BPO training; IIM Ahmedabad, IIM Calcutta, IIM Lucknow, Google for Management training. With IT hiring not doing too well this year, the ILS segment has diversified into other areas like Business Analytics. Non-IT courses have seen a 48% year on year increase in enrollments and have contributed to 17% of ILS revenues compared to 11% in the previous year. For FY 2012-13, ILS contributed to Rs 460 Crs of revenue and Rs 11 Crs of EBIDTA.

Corporate Learning Solutions (CLS)

The author of Running Training like a Business, Edward Trolley, Vice-President of Managed Training Services (MTS) at NIIT, used to work for DuPont`s training business before joining NIIT in 1996. In Argyle Conversations dated 28 August, 2012, Ed Trolley talks extensively about how global corporations are starting to see manpower training through a sharp business perspective. Unable to get answers on the return on investment for in-house training, global corporations have begun to outsource all training to reduce cost and improve the final outcome.

In line with this, NIIT`s MTS revenues have nearly tripled from Rs 85 Crs in FY 2011 to Rs 217 Crs in FY 13. As per NIIT`s Annual Report for 2012-13, their MTS customers include large multinationals from the Oil and Gas, Technology, Telecom and Financial Services sectors. The MTS division ended FY 13 with Rs 303 Crs of revenue and Rs 34 Crs of EBIDTA, contributing to 32% of the company`s revenues.

School Learning Solutions (SLS)

After burning their fingers with Government Build Own Operate Transfer (BOOT) contracts, the company has steadily increased the revenue share of non-government private schools to 59%. With its nGuru platform operating in more than 1800 schools all over India, NIIT derives nearly Rs 180 Crs of revenues and Rs 16 Crs of EBIDTA, contributing to 18% of the company`s revenues.

Skills Building Solutions (SBS)

Setup in a joint venture with the National Skills Development Corporation (NSDC), SBS currently has 34 locations offering 17 courses in diverse subjects like Auto retail, Hospitality etc.    

ELEMENTK DIVESTMENT

The company had acquired ElementK, one of the world`s largest comprehensive learning solutions provider in 2006, for a sum of $ 36.5 mi. In 2011, the company sold off ElementK for $ 110 mi, making a cool $ 58.5 mi profit. The proceeds from the sale were used to repay Rs 266 Crs of debt and shore up the balance sheet.

NIIT TECHNOLOGIES STAKE

The company has a 24% stake in NIIT Technologies Ltd, which was spun off from the company in 2004. This stake is currently valued at Rs 590 Crs, more than the enterprise valuation of the company itself.

ORIENT GLOBAL

In 2007, Intel Capital, the venture capital arm of the chip maker Intel, sold its 9.4 % stake in NIIT Ltd to Kiwi billionaire Richard Chandler`s Singapore based investment fund Orient Global for Rs 196 Crs. Intel Capital had converted its bonds into shares at Rs 44 Crs. The Rs 196 Cr sale was nearly a five – fold increase in acquisition. Currently, the same 9.4% is worth a meagre Rs 42 Crs.

FY 13 EARNINGS PROFILE

A general downturn in IT hiring has lead to a negative bottom line for FY 13. The company is on a cost rationalization drive and has laid off nearly 1000 employees in the last 2 years.

BUY RECOMMENDATION RATIONALE

–          Setup in 1981, by Mr Rajendra Pawar, a Padma Bhushan awardee and a member of the Prime Minister`s National Council on Skill development, and co-founders, Mr Vijay Thadani and Mr P.Rajendran, this company is one of the world`s best when it comes to IT training.

–          Its current enterprise valuation of Rs 550 Crs does not factor in the company`s 24% stake in NIIT Technologies.

–          NIIT is one of India`s most well known and trusted brands. The Rs 550 Crs enterprise valuation does a serious disservice to the NIIT brand which is quite well recognized not just in India, but also in the USA, Europe and China.

–          Orient Global had made an investment in this company for nearly 4.5 times the current price. The Orient Global acquisition and the current market price are an enactment of the irrational exuberance and extreme paranoia of capital markets. The fair value is somewhere in the middle of this price range.

–          For all practical purposes, NIIT is a debt free company, the Rs 112 Cr outstanding debt being literally insignificant in the larger context of things.

–          From a peak FII holding of 44% in 2007-08, currently FII`s hold only 14% stake in the company. The time of low FII holding is the best for a retail investor.

DISCLOSURE: I hold a substantial amount of shares in this company which was averaged at Rs 26/share.